Understanding Organisations

Regulators often spend much of their time and energy trying to change the behaviour of large organisations, including huge companies and large public sector institutions such as hospitals and universities.  It is therefore vital that regulators understand the likely behaviour of such organisations.  The organisations' Boards profess - and often believe - that they are excellent corporate citizens - even if Google no longer tells its employees to 'Do No Evil!'.  But they almost always act in their own self-interest, whilst their Boards may be totally unaware of the risks being run by junior employees and/or distant parts of the organisation. 

Regulators have too often failed to understand the risks that were being taken within their sector.  The result has been a number of catastrophic failures involving large, heavily-regulated organisations, including the 2007 worldwide collapse of financial institutions, the Grenfell Tower fire, the 2010 Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill, the certification of Boeing's 737-Max, and the mis-management of the Mid-Staffordshire Hospitals.

It is a mistake to approach the regulation of large organisations as though they are merely supersized versions of individual-led smaller firms. Most senior managers do not know (and some do not want to know) what is going on outside their head offices, nor what risks (financial, environmental and other) being taken by their staff.  Internal communications difficulties, compounded by the incentive to report good results, and senior executives' aversion to taking responsibility for errors, mean that senior managers are often the last to learn what is going wrong.  Regulators therefore need to take account of organisations' internal communications problems; the existence of herd behaviour and groupthink; and the culture and tensions that are typical of most large organisations. 

Here are some notes which go into more detail:-

 

Martin Stanley

Spotted something wrong?
Please do drop me an email if you spot anything that is out-of-date, or any other errors, typos or faulty links.